Organiser,2005 Issues > November 27, 2005
Think it over
Time to bridle the religious impulse
By M.S.N. Menon
Religions divide men. Politics divide men. Economics divide men. And culture divides men. Then, what is it that brings them together? The instinct of the herd?
Religions, the God-men tell us, are engaged in saving souls, in guiding men to salvation. But, how can these ?men of God?, who denounce the faith of others every day of their life, ever be a guide to mankind?
So, is there no hope for mankind? There is. But it has to begin with by making religion a personal affair, by banning the politicisation of religion.
Here are two religions?Christianity and Islam?which do not believe in the brotherhood of man. How can they, when they denounce men of other faiths?
?Religion, which was meant to make us better and nobler,? says Nehru, ?has made people behave like beasts.? They still behave like beasts, when seized with religious frenzy.
The point is: If religions turn human beings into beasts, what have the humanity done in the last thousands of years to prevent these beasts from usurping the power of the state to promote their beastliness? Very little. I think it is time to contain the beasts among us. And it is time to put religion on a new course.
For about 1500 years, Europe lived in the ?Age of Darkness?. This was the work of the beasts. They made it a felony to question the veracity and ?supernatural authority? of the Christian scriptures. In Islam, the punishment for apostasy was death.
The Reformation, the Renaissance and the Age of Reason finally broke the Christian spell over Europe. They brought light and reason. No such reform came the way of Islam to rescue it from the ulemas and mullahs. The mullahs still rule the world of Islam. In fact, Islam has remained impervious to every reform. ?How can we change the Word of God???this is the argument. True, the ?Word? has not changed, but the acts have changed. Read the fatwas?that is where the action takes place. They show the alarming extent of the distortions that have taken place in Islam.
If we have thus found no way to control the beasts in our times, it is largely because the beasts are under the protection and patronage of the rulers?the new priests of our times. They want the votes of the beasts.
Today the whole fraternity of evil men?the beasts, politicians, criminals?are in a league. They help each other to stay in power. Did we anticipate this? No. We were told that the disciples of Mahatma Gandhi could do no wrong. We believed it. But such things were said before?that the disciples of Jesus Christ could do no wrong, that disciples of Prophet Mohammed could do no wrong. We know the consequences of such naivety. But did it prevent us from believing the claim of the Marxists? No. We believed their claims too!
Where men have failed, the Law should have spoken. But the makers of the Indian Constitution did not ban the men of religion from politics after the horrendous experience of India?s Partition. But that is to assume that they were sensitive to the tragedy. They were not. Here was the most terrible and traumatic event in the history of India and it passed by our Constitution makers and academia without making the least impression on them! Did they try to control the beasts through constitutional measures? They did not. In fact, they tried to protect the beasts. We are all paying the price for this folly. And our academic community has remained a mute witness of this continuing folly.
Religion and politics have for long been separate among Hindus. Why? Because Hinduism is the most mature of all religions. But our Constitution makers were not aware of it. Which explains why they did not insist on the separation of religion and politics. What is worse, they allowed Islam to control every aspect of a Muslim?s life, thus introducing a theocracy within the larger framework of our democracy. An act of subversion of our Constitution? Yes.
The beasts are thus trying to drag mankind to the days of tribal wars, with their tribal gods egging on the tribes to destroy each other. We cannot allow this perversion to continue. Religions are of no use to us today to understand the universe we live in. If it serves any other purpose, it is time to say so. The religious impulse is no doubt a powerful social force. It can promote the ideal of a socialised state. But that is not the goal the ?men of God? are pursuing today. Some have gone to the extent of terrorising the humanity!
Thursday, 1 October 2009
Truth can kill the West
Organiser,2005 Issues > December 04, 2005
Think it over
Truth can kill the West
By M.S.N. Menon
Truth can kill the West?the truth about Christianity. It is all in the Dead Sea scrolls.
The Dead Sea scrolls were discovered in 1947. But nothing has been done to reveal their truth. In fact, the Church was so secretive about them that it made them inaccessible to even religious authorities.
The secrecy continued till 1991. On September 22, 1991 the Huntington Library of California, which had photocopies of all Dead Sea scrolls, released them. The Vatican, which was worried about the contents of the scrolls, was naturally outraged.
What is the untold story in the Dead Sea scrolls? Perhaps we will never know fully. We know now that an extremist Jewish sect, which had revolted against Jewish orthodoxy, were perhaps the authors of the scrolls. They lived in Qumran (a Palestinian mountain region). But Qumran was destroyed by the Romans during 66-74 AD. Or in an earthquake. And with that we have lost much of the story of the Essene, too, a Buddhist sect which lived in Qumran. But on them later.
The Qumran sect believed that a Messiah would be born among them with a new message. It is said that the Gospel writers were inspired by this Messiah. Perhaps Jesus is a fiction?
The Qumran scrolls, it is believed, were written 100-200 years before the birth of Christ. It even talked of a ?Son of God?.
We know now that the leader of the early church of Jerusalem was not Jesus, but a man called James, the Righteous?a minor figure in the Bible. Biblical scholars say that the destruction could have been carried out by Saul (St. Paul). Latter, he got converted to the Qumran lore. Hence early Chritianity was called ?Pauline Christianity?.
The scrolls reveal that Jews had nothing to do with the killing of Jesus Christ. It was all a fabricated story. If this is the truth, the Jews have a cause celebre against the Christian world for the persecution they suffered for 2,000 years. This is yet another reason why the Christian church would want the story to remain untold.
It is very clear that early Christianity was Qumranian. James was a Jew, but a revolutionary, which explains the revolutionary nature of his doctrines. He believed in ahimsa (non-violence) and said that ?the Kingdom of God is within you? ?an idea purely Hindu-Buddhist. They could not have come either from Greece or Jewish sources. But Pauline Christianity was anti-James. St. Paul gave it a new direction. Christianity, as it exists today, may turn out to be the greatest deception on the Christian world.
But one day the truth will be out. It cannot remain hidden for ever. Pope Leo X (1513-21) admitted centuries ago: ?It has served us well this myth of Christ.? (In my article of October 9, 2005, I said that a bishops? Commission rejected the claim that Jesus was crucified. Islam refused to acknowledge it to this day?author)
It was this myth and others of its kind that the scrolls threatened to expose. The Germans were the first to be uneasy about these tall claims of the church. Hence the revolt of Luther against Rome. ?By absorbing so many elements from other religions, Christianity had come to offer more than any one of them could offer by itself?, says Northcote Parkinson. So much for the claim to originality!
According to Pliny ( Roman historian) and Josephus (Jewish historian), the Essene had existed on the banks of the Jordan and the East Bank of the Dead Sea for at least 150 years before Jesus. They were engaged in teaching Buddhism. The Jewish historian H.Graetz called Christianity ?Essenism with foreign elements?. This alone can explain the non-violence they preached in a region notorious for its violence!
Pliny, the Elder, describes the Essene as ?a lonely people...without any women, who have renounced human love and live quite pennilessly under the palms?. Little was known of them till the discovery of the scrolls in Qumran.
So, was there a historical figure called Jesus Christ? Was he a student of Buddhism? Was he crucified? Was there a resurrection? The future of Christianity will depend on the answers. They can change the course of human history.
Herbert Mueller writes: ?The Synoptic gospels make clear that Jesus did not make open claims to divinity... he did not offer salvation through a redeeming Lord... (But) the church went on to make him equal to God and to insist that salvation was possible only through Jesus Christ.?
The gulf between the Jesus of history and the Christ of faith is so wide today that Christianity is dying today in the West. It is quite evident that the Christianity we know today is a reconstruction by the church to suit its objectives. When all these and other matters will come to be known from the Qumran scrolls, the Christian world will be ready to die of shame. But the Christ of faith will perhaps live on. As a Buddhist?
Think it over
Truth can kill the West
By M.S.N. Menon
Truth can kill the West?the truth about Christianity. It is all in the Dead Sea scrolls.
The Dead Sea scrolls were discovered in 1947. But nothing has been done to reveal their truth. In fact, the Church was so secretive about them that it made them inaccessible to even religious authorities.
The secrecy continued till 1991. On September 22, 1991 the Huntington Library of California, which had photocopies of all Dead Sea scrolls, released them. The Vatican, which was worried about the contents of the scrolls, was naturally outraged.
What is the untold story in the Dead Sea scrolls? Perhaps we will never know fully. We know now that an extremist Jewish sect, which had revolted against Jewish orthodoxy, were perhaps the authors of the scrolls. They lived in Qumran (a Palestinian mountain region). But Qumran was destroyed by the Romans during 66-74 AD. Or in an earthquake. And with that we have lost much of the story of the Essene, too, a Buddhist sect which lived in Qumran. But on them later.
The Qumran sect believed that a Messiah would be born among them with a new message. It is said that the Gospel writers were inspired by this Messiah. Perhaps Jesus is a fiction?
The Qumran scrolls, it is believed, were written 100-200 years before the birth of Christ. It even talked of a ?Son of God?.
We know now that the leader of the early church of Jerusalem was not Jesus, but a man called James, the Righteous?a minor figure in the Bible. Biblical scholars say that the destruction could have been carried out by Saul (St. Paul). Latter, he got converted to the Qumran lore. Hence early Chritianity was called ?Pauline Christianity?.
The scrolls reveal that Jews had nothing to do with the killing of Jesus Christ. It was all a fabricated story. If this is the truth, the Jews have a cause celebre against the Christian world for the persecution they suffered for 2,000 years. This is yet another reason why the Christian church would want the story to remain untold.
It is very clear that early Christianity was Qumranian. James was a Jew, but a revolutionary, which explains the revolutionary nature of his doctrines. He believed in ahimsa (non-violence) and said that ?the Kingdom of God is within you? ?an idea purely Hindu-Buddhist. They could not have come either from Greece or Jewish sources. But Pauline Christianity was anti-James. St. Paul gave it a new direction. Christianity, as it exists today, may turn out to be the greatest deception on the Christian world.
But one day the truth will be out. It cannot remain hidden for ever. Pope Leo X (1513-21) admitted centuries ago: ?It has served us well this myth of Christ.? (In my article of October 9, 2005, I said that a bishops? Commission rejected the claim that Jesus was crucified. Islam refused to acknowledge it to this day?author)
It was this myth and others of its kind that the scrolls threatened to expose. The Germans were the first to be uneasy about these tall claims of the church. Hence the revolt of Luther against Rome. ?By absorbing so many elements from other religions, Christianity had come to offer more than any one of them could offer by itself?, says Northcote Parkinson. So much for the claim to originality!
According to Pliny ( Roman historian) and Josephus (Jewish historian), the Essene had existed on the banks of the Jordan and the East Bank of the Dead Sea for at least 150 years before Jesus. They were engaged in teaching Buddhism. The Jewish historian H.Graetz called Christianity ?Essenism with foreign elements?. This alone can explain the non-violence they preached in a region notorious for its violence!
Pliny, the Elder, describes the Essene as ?a lonely people...without any women, who have renounced human love and live quite pennilessly under the palms?. Little was known of them till the discovery of the scrolls in Qumran.
So, was there a historical figure called Jesus Christ? Was he a student of Buddhism? Was he crucified? Was there a resurrection? The future of Christianity will depend on the answers. They can change the course of human history.
Herbert Mueller writes: ?The Synoptic gospels make clear that Jesus did not make open claims to divinity... he did not offer salvation through a redeeming Lord... (But) the church went on to make him equal to God and to insist that salvation was possible only through Jesus Christ.?
The gulf between the Jesus of history and the Christ of faith is so wide today that Christianity is dying today in the West. It is quite evident that the Christianity we know today is a reconstruction by the church to suit its objectives. When all these and other matters will come to be known from the Qumran scrolls, the Christian world will be ready to die of shame. But the Christ of faith will perhaps live on. As a Buddhist?
Labels:
2010,
Christianity,
Church,
Communist,
Comonwealth Games,
Hindu,
India,
New Delhi
A plot to conquer India by conversion
Organiser,2008 Issues > November 02, 2008
A plot to conquer India by conversion
By JG Arora
Hindus in India and Nepal are prime targets for this harvest of faith. Even if old horrors like Goa Inquisition (1560 to 1812) heaped on Hindus by the church are kept aside, what is happening now is equally horrible.
The so-called ?secular? India has proved to be a disaster for Hindus. To prevent the creation of more Pakistans and Bangladeshs on Bharat?s soil by countless Pak-Bangla terrorists and infiltrators, and to prevent more Hindu lands (like North-East India) going to missionaries, ?secular India? has to be transformed into ?Hindu Bharat?.
Since Bharat has forgotten its ancient Sanskrit adage, ?Shathe shaathyam samaacharet? (treat the wicked in his own wicked way), its tormentors are having a free run.
Expansionist forces are waging a relentless war to demolish Hinduism and Hindu civilisation the way they have already wiped out many native religions and cultures from Europe, America, Africa, Australia, New Zealand, numerous Islands and parts of Asia.
On August 23, 2008, just before Krishnajanmashtami, an important Hindu festival, 84 years old Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati and four other Hindu sages were gunned down in girls hostel at Kandhamal in Orissa. Their only crime was that they were resisting fraudulent conversions by foreign-funded Christian missionaries.
At present, the worst problems faced by India are the demographic invasion by crores of Pak-Bangla infiltrators, and conversion of Hindus to Christianity through fraud and charade of charity by missionaries.
If Pak-Bangla combine wants to Islamise India through countless terrorists and infiltrators, missionaries want to Christianise India through unlimited foreign funds.
Unilateral war
Though religious freedom can never mean the freedom to convert; and though in 1977, vide its judgement reported as Rev. Stainislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1977 SC 908), the Supreme Court held that Article 25 (1) of Indian Constitution does not grant any right to convert any person to one?s own religion, there is no halt to aggressive evangelisation.
While addressing missionaries in New Delhi on November 7, 1999, the late Pope John Paul II gave a call to convert Asia to Christianity as follows:-
?Just as the first millennium saw the cross firmly planted in the soil of Europe, and the second in that of America and Africa, so may the Third Christian Millennium witness a great harvest of faith on this vast and vital continent.?
And his successor and present Pope Benedict XVI reiterated conversion agenda with the words, ?The church is by its very nature missionary; its first task is evangelisation.?
Hindus in India and Nepal are prime targets for this harvest of faith. Even if old horrors like Goa Inquisition (1560 to 1812) heaped on Hindus by the church are kept aside, what is happening now is equally horrible.
Having already conquered North-East India, many global missionary organisations are sending enormous funds to non-governmental organisations (NGOs) in India for converting Hindus to Christianity through fraud, allurement and coercion.
Reinhard Bonnke, the global evangelist famous for his crusades in Africa, has diverted his attention to India. Pat Robertson, the American founder of Christian Broadcasting Network (CBN), also wants aggressive evangelisation of India.
Missionaries are far superior in marketing than any MBA. Within a few decades, they converted Buddhist South Korea into a Christian majority country. And they want to repeat that success in India.
Conversion blitzkrieg
Missionary activity in India is aimed at destroying Hindu religion and culture; and has nothing to do with spirituality. While many Hindu religious leaders are parroting the dangerous falsity that all religions are the same (sarvadharmasambhav), missionaries are demolishing Hinduism by converting Hindus.
Several global missionary organisations were running a co-ordinated conversion campaign in India known as AD 2000. These activities were later brought under the Joshua Project.
Joshua Project is a war-like project to invade and Christianise India. It has collected the necessary population data about each village and town in India, and has prepared the area specific strategy to bring maximum conversions.
All over India, churches are being built even in remote villages (with no Christian population) to Christianise the local populations. Entire India is facing a blitzkrieg of missionary aggression.
As reported in a section of media, D. Ron Watts, a Canadian missionary and Dorothy Watts, his American wife, and their cohorts have converted several lakhs of vulnerable Hindus to Christianity in Andhra Pradesh during the last few years. Though they came to India on Business visas, they were engaged in conversions violating their visa terms.
Tamil Nadu government?s revocation of anti-conversion law has further boosted conversions in Tamil Nadu.
Missionaries are targetting Sikhs too; and after converting 56 Sikhs to Christianity at Goindwal Sahib, a Sikh holy place in Punjab in 2005, they have stepped up such activities.
Fraudulent exploitation
Conversion of vulnerable Hindus through fraud and inducement is a big industry in India employing hundreds of thousands of missionaries wearing the mask of social service. More Hindus they convert, more money they get.
In his write-up, ?The war against Hinduism?, Stephen Knapp has described various subterfuges employed to get convert to Christianity in India. Missionaries give loans to vulnerable Hindus who cannot repay. The said loans stand waived the moment the debtors become Christian. And more rewards await those who bring more Hindus to the church. He has also described stage-managed mass healings for mass conversions. And then there are ?miracle boxes? kept in churches where the poor can write their wishes which are fulfilled to bring them to Christianity.
To induce conversions, some missionaries bear Hindu names, dress like Hindu sannyasis, and call their organisations Ashrams.
Evangelists treat natural calamities as opportunities to purchase new converts. They offer relief to helpless victims of tragedy in exchange of their religion. Tsunami that struck Tamil Nadu in 2004 saw mass proselytisation of vulnerable Hindus. At some places hit by tsunami, Christian groups refused to give relief supplies when the victims refused to change their faith.
Predators or ?victims??
Missionaries pretend to be ?victims? if their predatory attempts at proselytisation are resisted.
Recent circulation of a number of contrived stories about the alleged attacks on Christians in mainstream anti-Hindu media suppresses the fact that Hindu reaction in Orissa was triggered by the murder of Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati, and in Karnataka by denigration of Hindu gods in the book, Satya Darshini? distributed by some missionaries.
Unfortunately, most of the mainstream media in India is anti-Hindu, and hides missionary aggression. But it dubs those resenting this aggression as ?communal?. While the said media ignored the outrageous murder of Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati, as also the denigration of Hinduism in Satya Darshini, it over-blew the natural Hindu reaction following these appalling attacks on Hindus and Hindu faith.
Way out
Since those who behave like sheep, are eaten by the wolves, much of the injury suffered by Hindus is self-inflicted by their capitulation before their tormentors.
Ever since 1947, Indian government?s policy of perverse secularism (which in reality means anti-Hinduism) has been leading to gradual liquidation of Hindu Bharat.
The so-called ?secular? India has proved to be a disaster for Hindus. To prevent the creation of more Pakistans and Bangladeshs on Bharat?s soil by countless Pak-Bangla terrorists and infiltrators, and to prevent more Hindu lands (like North-East India) going to missionaries, ?secular India ? has to be transformed into ?Hindu Bharat?.
Logically, in 1947, on India?s Partition on religious basis and creation of Pakistan as demanded by Muslims, Bharat should have been declared a Hindu nation. But the problem can be solved even now by declaring Bharat a Hindu country. No one can object to Bharat being declared a Hindu nation when all the 57 Muslim-majority countries are declared as Islamic countries, and many Christian majority countries are Christian countries.
Hindu Bharat will give justice to all and appease none. In Hindu Bharat, there will be one law and one nation; no distinction of majority and minority; and no discrimination, whatsoever, against any community.
Apart from protecting Bharat?s Hindu identity, Hindu Bharat will crush the daily Pak-Bangla terrorist attacks and demographic invasion, as also foreign-funded missionaries? conversion menace. Hindu Bharat will ban the inflow of foreign funds meant for subversion and conversion, and will also ban conversions effected by fraud, allurement or coercion. Hindu Bharat will also remove laws which discriminate against Hindus.
Accordingly, for the very survival of Hindus and Hinduism, all pro-Hindu individuals and organisations must unite to transform India into a Hindu nation by all peaceful, constitutional and lawful means.
Hindu Bharat will ensure that Hinduism survives and prevails. And that will be the apt tribute to Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati and his associates who sacrificed their lives while defending Hinduism.
(The writer is former Chief Commissioner of Income Tax and can be contacted at jgarora@gmail.com)
A plot to conquer India by conversion
By JG Arora
Hindus in India and Nepal are prime targets for this harvest of faith. Even if old horrors like Goa Inquisition (1560 to 1812) heaped on Hindus by the church are kept aside, what is happening now is equally horrible.
The so-called ?secular? India has proved to be a disaster for Hindus. To prevent the creation of more Pakistans and Bangladeshs on Bharat?s soil by countless Pak-Bangla terrorists and infiltrators, and to prevent more Hindu lands (like North-East India) going to missionaries, ?secular India? has to be transformed into ?Hindu Bharat?.
Since Bharat has forgotten its ancient Sanskrit adage, ?Shathe shaathyam samaacharet? (treat the wicked in his own wicked way), its tormentors are having a free run.
Expansionist forces are waging a relentless war to demolish Hinduism and Hindu civilisation the way they have already wiped out many native religions and cultures from Europe, America, Africa, Australia, New Zealand, numerous Islands and parts of Asia.
On August 23, 2008, just before Krishnajanmashtami, an important Hindu festival, 84 years old Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati and four other Hindu sages were gunned down in girls hostel at Kandhamal in Orissa. Their only crime was that they were resisting fraudulent conversions by foreign-funded Christian missionaries.
At present, the worst problems faced by India are the demographic invasion by crores of Pak-Bangla infiltrators, and conversion of Hindus to Christianity through fraud and charade of charity by missionaries.
If Pak-Bangla combine wants to Islamise India through countless terrorists and infiltrators, missionaries want to Christianise India through unlimited foreign funds.
Unilateral war
Though religious freedom can never mean the freedom to convert; and though in 1977, vide its judgement reported as Rev. Stainislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1977 SC 908), the Supreme Court held that Article 25 (1) of Indian Constitution does not grant any right to convert any person to one?s own religion, there is no halt to aggressive evangelisation.
While addressing missionaries in New Delhi on November 7, 1999, the late Pope John Paul II gave a call to convert Asia to Christianity as follows:-
?Just as the first millennium saw the cross firmly planted in the soil of Europe, and the second in that of America and Africa, so may the Third Christian Millennium witness a great harvest of faith on this vast and vital continent.?
And his successor and present Pope Benedict XVI reiterated conversion agenda with the words, ?The church is by its very nature missionary; its first task is evangelisation.?
Hindus in India and Nepal are prime targets for this harvest of faith. Even if old horrors like Goa Inquisition (1560 to 1812) heaped on Hindus by the church are kept aside, what is happening now is equally horrible.
Having already conquered North-East India, many global missionary organisations are sending enormous funds to non-governmental organisations (NGOs) in India for converting Hindus to Christianity through fraud, allurement and coercion.
Reinhard Bonnke, the global evangelist famous for his crusades in Africa, has diverted his attention to India. Pat Robertson, the American founder of Christian Broadcasting Network (CBN), also wants aggressive evangelisation of India.
Missionaries are far superior in marketing than any MBA. Within a few decades, they converted Buddhist South Korea into a Christian majority country. And they want to repeat that success in India.
Conversion blitzkrieg
Missionary activity in India is aimed at destroying Hindu religion and culture; and has nothing to do with spirituality. While many Hindu religious leaders are parroting the dangerous falsity that all religions are the same (sarvadharmasambhav), missionaries are demolishing Hinduism by converting Hindus.
Several global missionary organisations were running a co-ordinated conversion campaign in India known as AD 2000. These activities were later brought under the Joshua Project.
Joshua Project is a war-like project to invade and Christianise India. It has collected the necessary population data about each village and town in India, and has prepared the area specific strategy to bring maximum conversions.
All over India, churches are being built even in remote villages (with no Christian population) to Christianise the local populations. Entire India is facing a blitzkrieg of missionary aggression.
As reported in a section of media, D. Ron Watts, a Canadian missionary and Dorothy Watts, his American wife, and their cohorts have converted several lakhs of vulnerable Hindus to Christianity in Andhra Pradesh during the last few years. Though they came to India on Business visas, they were engaged in conversions violating their visa terms.
Tamil Nadu government?s revocation of anti-conversion law has further boosted conversions in Tamil Nadu.
Missionaries are targetting Sikhs too; and after converting 56 Sikhs to Christianity at Goindwal Sahib, a Sikh holy place in Punjab in 2005, they have stepped up such activities.
Fraudulent exploitation
Conversion of vulnerable Hindus through fraud and inducement is a big industry in India employing hundreds of thousands of missionaries wearing the mask of social service. More Hindus they convert, more money they get.
In his write-up, ?The war against Hinduism?, Stephen Knapp has described various subterfuges employed to get convert to Christianity in India. Missionaries give loans to vulnerable Hindus who cannot repay. The said loans stand waived the moment the debtors become Christian. And more rewards await those who bring more Hindus to the church. He has also described stage-managed mass healings for mass conversions. And then there are ?miracle boxes? kept in churches where the poor can write their wishes which are fulfilled to bring them to Christianity.
To induce conversions, some missionaries bear Hindu names, dress like Hindu sannyasis, and call their organisations Ashrams.
Evangelists treat natural calamities as opportunities to purchase new converts. They offer relief to helpless victims of tragedy in exchange of their religion. Tsunami that struck Tamil Nadu in 2004 saw mass proselytisation of vulnerable Hindus. At some places hit by tsunami, Christian groups refused to give relief supplies when the victims refused to change their faith.
Predators or ?victims??
Missionaries pretend to be ?victims? if their predatory attempts at proselytisation are resisted.
Recent circulation of a number of contrived stories about the alleged attacks on Christians in mainstream anti-Hindu media suppresses the fact that Hindu reaction in Orissa was triggered by the murder of Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati, and in Karnataka by denigration of Hindu gods in the book, Satya Darshini? distributed by some missionaries.
Unfortunately, most of the mainstream media in India is anti-Hindu, and hides missionary aggression. But it dubs those resenting this aggression as ?communal?. While the said media ignored the outrageous murder of Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati, as also the denigration of Hinduism in Satya Darshini, it over-blew the natural Hindu reaction following these appalling attacks on Hindus and Hindu faith.
Way out
Since those who behave like sheep, are eaten by the wolves, much of the injury suffered by Hindus is self-inflicted by their capitulation before their tormentors.
Ever since 1947, Indian government?s policy of perverse secularism (which in reality means anti-Hinduism) has been leading to gradual liquidation of Hindu Bharat.
The so-called ?secular? India has proved to be a disaster for Hindus. To prevent the creation of more Pakistans and Bangladeshs on Bharat?s soil by countless Pak-Bangla terrorists and infiltrators, and to prevent more Hindu lands (like North-East India) going to missionaries, ?secular India ? has to be transformed into ?Hindu Bharat?.
Logically, in 1947, on India?s Partition on religious basis and creation of Pakistan as demanded by Muslims, Bharat should have been declared a Hindu nation. But the problem can be solved even now by declaring Bharat a Hindu country. No one can object to Bharat being declared a Hindu nation when all the 57 Muslim-majority countries are declared as Islamic countries, and many Christian majority countries are Christian countries.
Hindu Bharat will give justice to all and appease none. In Hindu Bharat, there will be one law and one nation; no distinction of majority and minority; and no discrimination, whatsoever, against any community.
Apart from protecting Bharat?s Hindu identity, Hindu Bharat will crush the daily Pak-Bangla terrorist attacks and demographic invasion, as also foreign-funded missionaries? conversion menace. Hindu Bharat will ban the inflow of foreign funds meant for subversion and conversion, and will also ban conversions effected by fraud, allurement or coercion. Hindu Bharat will also remove laws which discriminate against Hindus.
Accordingly, for the very survival of Hindus and Hinduism, all pro-Hindu individuals and organisations must unite to transform India into a Hindu nation by all peaceful, constitutional and lawful means.
Hindu Bharat will ensure that Hinduism survives and prevails. And that will be the apt tribute to Swami Laxmanananda Saraswati and his associates who sacrificed their lives while defending Hinduism.
(The writer is former Chief Commissioner of Income Tax and can be contacted at jgarora@gmail.com)
Labels:
2010,
Christianity,
Church,
Communist,
Comonwealth Games,
Hindu,
India,
New Delhi
Planned attempt in Tirupathi by evangelists to defile the great holy shrine
Organiser,2006 Issues > July 16, 2006
Planned attempt in Tirupathi by evangelists to defile the great holy shrine
Startling revelation by the fact-finding committee Congress patronage suspected
From Our Special Correspondent
His Holiness Sri Vishwesha Teertha of Pejawar Mutt, Udipi, requested Justice G. Bikshapathy, Justice K.B. Siddappa, former Judges of Andhra Pradesh High Court, Shri T.S. Rao, former Director General of Police, Andhra Pradesh, Dr. P. Geervani, former Vice-Chancellor of Padmavathi Mahila Vishwavidyalaya and Dr R. Srihari, former Vice-Chancellor of Dravidian University, Kuppam, to function as a fact-finding committee under the chairmanship of Justice G. Bikshapathy to ascertain the factual position as regards the activities of non-Hindu religious communities in Tirumala and Tirupathi.
Many people from Christian and Muslim communities were being employed in the TTD and some of the Hindu employees were even converted as Christians and they practice Christianity. About 40 families in Balaji Colony are Christians. They hold congregations and prayers on Sundays.
Only Hindus are to be appointed as employees in the TTD under the rule. However, the EO stated that for some period this was not followed with the result that some Muslim personnel came to be appointed. He further stated that steps are being taken to shift them to some other places gradually. Some employees in the TTD also profess Christianity and that in the police quarters also congregations and prayers are conducted regularly.
Discontinued the practice of garlanding the portraits of Lord Venkateswara and Goddess Padmavathi everyday. Instead she kept a portrait of Jesus Christ and the Cross on her office table. She sends batches of students in the university buses to the church. It is also stated that in the Mahila University, the students are not allowed to have tilak on the forehead now-a-days and that students putting tilak are being discriminated.
Cow slaughter is taking place in down hill at Tirupathi near D.R. Mahal. The meat is being transported to Tirumala clandestinely. TTD Kalyana Mandapam at Nagalapuram is being used by the Christians for their prayer congregations and for performance of Christian marriages. Near Sree Rama and Siva Temple in Tirupathi, Christian prayers and propaganda take place by intercepting the Hindu devotees visiting the temples.
Sri Vishwesha Teertha Swamiji of the Pejawar Mutt in response to startling disclosures of the planned evangelist activities in the holy Tirupathi temple premises announced that the leaders of Hindu mutts would meet in the temple complex on July 15 to discuss the activities of Christian missionaries, including attempts to convert Hindus in Tirumala and Tirupathi.
The Swami said it was disturbing that Christian missionaries had selected these places to carry out conversions. ?We will meet in Hyderabad on July 11 and then in Tirupathi on July 15 to chalk out our course of action,? he said. He was speaking after receiving a report from a fact-finding committee on this issue and sent by him to Tirupathi. The committee visited Tirumala and Tirupathi last month and held meetings with people there before preparing the report.
?As a Hindu saint, I am worried about the conversion activity taking place there, which was why I constituted the committee to look into the matter,? he said.
Shri D. Bheemasena Rao, the convenor of the Tirumala Tirupathi Samrakshana Samiti, said the July 15 meeting is likely to chalk out a mass awareness programme against conversion. Retired Andhra Pradesh Director General of Police, Shri T.S. Rao, who was a member of the fact-finding committee, said that 15 to 20 families in Tirumala have been converted in the past two years. He alleged that the vice-chancellors of the Padmavathi and Venkateshwara universities were using coercive methods to convert students to Christianity. ?During public interactions, we were told that students who had enrolled for PhDs were being pressurised to convert. They have even been told that they would not get their doctorate unless they converted,? he added.
Dravida University?s former Vice-Chancellor Dr R. Srihari maintained that Christian missionaries had chosen some important places of worship in Andhra Pradesh as part of their strategy, which was why they had moved to Tirumala and Tirupathi for this exercise.
The following is the full text of the high-level committee?s report:
The Committee found that members of the Christian community distributed religious pamphlets and copies of the Bible to the students who were returning after writing the EAMCET examinations conducted at various centres in Tirupathi in May 2006. Apart from other persons, who deposed before the Committee, this information was also disclosed by the son of Shri Prabhakara Acharya, Secretary of Vaikhanasa Ashram at Tirumala, who appeared for the EAMCET examinations. This activity of the Christians led to serious tense situation in Tirupathi. It was also revealed to the Committee that a large number of women and men, dividing themselves into several groups, distributed Christian religious material at various places including EAMCET centres. Some student organisations protested against these activities. Police had to intervene to maintain law and order.
On April 9, 2006, two Christians by name Balaraju (pastor) and Babu while coming down from Tirumala to Tirupathi in bus bearing No. AP 11Z 1130 distributed pamphlets propagating Christianity to the pilgrims travelling in that bus. One of the passengers Shri Arvind of Hyderabad complained the matter to the AV&SO Shri S. Sivananda Kishore, who after enquiry, gave a report on 11.4.2006 to the Vigilance and Security Officer, TTD. Basing on his report, a case in crime No. 8/2006 was registered against S. Balaraju and P. Babu, residents of Tirupathi and the police took up investigation. On the basis of the said complaint, Shri R. Sivananda Kishore (AV&SO, Sector-III, TTD, Tirumala), in his report recommended as follows:
?In the light of instant case, the following recommendations may be considered to avoid recurrence of such incidents in future.
As per Rule 197 of APCHR and E Act 1987 the population living in Tirumala shall adhere to the norms and shall follow the sentiments of Hindu Religion. As such a thorough probe has to be taken up to verify the antecedents of non-Hindu employees who are working in TTD as well as government departments, i.e. police, fire services, commercial taxes, etc., who are staying in Tirumala. The identified employees and their families shall be shifted from Tirumala.
His Holiness Sri Vishwesha Teertha of Pejawar Mutt, Udipi, requested Justice G. Bikshapathy, Justice K.B. Siddappa, former Judges of Andhra Pradesh High Court, Shri T.S. Rao, former Director General of Police, Andhra Pradesh, Dr. P. Geervani, former Vice-Chancellor of Padmavathi Mahila Vishwavidyalaya and Dr. R. Srihari, former Vice-Chancellor of Dravidian University, Kuppam, to function as a fact-finding committee under the chairmanship of Justice G. Bikshapathy to ascertain the factual position as regards the activities of non-Hindu religious communities in Tirumala and Tirupathi and to furnish a report to His Holiness for considering the steps to be taken to prevent undesirable activities of the Christian and other non-Hindu communities.
Some of the family members of the TTD employees such as wife and children are practicing Christian ideology and inviting the pastors to conduct prayers in their homes at Tirumala, the committee found.
In the Rule 198 of APCHR&E Act 1987 the following activities are prohibited at Tirumala:-
(A) Carrying and possession of holy books of other religions like Bible, Quran etc. (B) Any kind of propagation of other than Hindu religion by way of distribution of pamphlets, literature, brochures, stickers, banners, flags, including prayers and speeches etc.
Two Christian women belonging to Chilakuluripet were found in the TTD queue complex and they were caught red-handed on 26.4.2006 distributing religious pamphlets to the pilgrims in the queue and were handed over to the Deputy Superintendent of Police at Tirumala by the pilgrims themselves. The Committee was informed that the Vigilance personnel took into custody these two Christian women and produced them before the DSP, Tirumala. The Committee was told that the Special Officer got released those two women after questioning them and arranged special darshan and gave prasadam. When the Committee met the Executive Officer on 22.06.2006, Special Officer Shri Dharma Reddy was present and he told the Committee that those two women came from an old-age home, run by a Christian mission and they stated that as per the wish of some of the inmates of the old-age home who were suffering from AIDS, they came to get prasadam for distributing it to those inmates, and on that representation of the two women, he permitted them to have darshan after signing the requisite declaration and gave them prasadam. No name of the old-age home was disclosed.
It is highly unlikely that a Christian would travel long distance to visit Tirumala to collect prasadam offered by a Hindu religious temple to be given to the inmates of an old-age home run by a Christian mission. The two women did not disclose to the TTD officials concerned before entering the queue complex that they were Christians, and they got into the queue complex without signing the requisite declaration and obtaining permission of the TTD officials concerned.
Two Christians David (pastor) and Kumar were found propagating Christianity in Tirumala and they were handed over to police. The police registered a case and kept them for two days on remand. Those two persons admitted that they committed a mistake. This was also confirmed by the EO, TTD who stated that the two were indulging in religious propaganda. However, strangely the Special Officer, Shri Dharma Reddy, stated that they did not indulge in any Christian propaganda. The two Christians were eventually released without taking any action against them.
On May 21, 2006, Special Officer Shri Dharma Reddy held a press conference in which he stated that no Christian religious propaganda was going on in Tirumala. It is evident that he is not taking a serious view of these objectionable activities of the Christians at the holy place of Tirumala.
Propagation of Christian religion in educational institutions in Tirupathi
Educational institutions at Tirupathi were established on TTD land and with TTD funds. But in the colleges and hostel at Tirupathi, Christian religious propagation is rampant. The Christian students themselves act as propagators. Shri Deva Sangeetham, Principal of S.V. University College, openly indulges in propagating and converting the students to Christianity by making them go to Church, reading the Bible and creating disaffection towards Hindu religion. After Shri Deva Sangeetham has taken charge as Principal, the practice of garlanding the portrait of Lord Venkateswara is stopped.
After Smt. Veena Noble Das took charge as Vice-Chancellor of Padmavathi Mahila University, she got removed the photos of Lord Venkateswara and Goddess Padmavathi from all the institutions of the Mahila University and she also got removed the portrait of Lord Venkateswara from her office and discontinued the practice of garlanding the portraits of Lord Venkateswara and Goddess Padmavathi everyday. Instead she kept a portrait of Jesus Christ and the Cross on her office table. She sends batches of students in the university buses to the church. It is also stated that in the Mahila University, the students are not allowed to have tilak on the forehead now-a-days and that students putting tilak are being discriminated.
Employment in the TTD
Only Hindus are to be appointed as employees in the TTD under the rule. However, the EO stated that for some period this was not followed with the result that some Muslim personnel came to be appointed. He further stated that steps are being taken to shift them to some other places gradually. Some employees in the TTD profess Christianity and that in the police quarters also congregations and prayers are conducted regularly. There are about 40 Christian families residing in Tirumala and they hold religious congregations at their homes on Sundays. It is stated that even in the Annadanam Complex there is an employee, Shri Ananda Raju belonging to Christian community, working as Superintendent. The EO has stated that he will enquire and take action. Another Christian woman works in the electrical department. Gopinath, Garden Superintendent, also belongs to Christian community.
Non-Hindu employees of TTD and their activities
It is brought to the notice of the Committee that many people from Christian and Muslim communities were being employed in the TTD and some of the Hindu employees were even converted as Christians and they practice Christianity. About 40 families in Balaji Colony are Christians. They hold congregations and prayers on Sundays.
The Committee was informed that Gopinath, who was posted on deputation as Garden Superintendent, is a Christian and that he criticises worshipping Lord Venkateswara saying why should a black stone be decorated with garlands, and that he indulges in criticising Hindu Religion.
Considering the above facts and circumstances, the propagation of Christianity with an ulterior motive of conversion is taking place in Tirupathi and Tirumala. Since the EO has categorically assured the Committee that no such incidents will be allowed to take place, the matter has to be reviewed periodically.
Scouts and guides
In the queue complex number of scouts and guides are deployed to regulate the pilgrims. It is understood that details of the religion of the persons who are so engaged is not verified and that some of them belong to non-Hindu communities. The scouts and guides are allowed into the main temple and to have darshan. The Executive Officer has informed the Committee that he would take appropriate measures to prevent non-Hindus being deployed as scouts and guides in Tirumala.
Hawkers and shopkeepers
There are number of hawkers who belong to Muslim community. Two instances are given. Shop Nos. 192 and 72 in the shopping complex are run by Shri Jamal Khadar and Maithri. When this was brought to the notice of EO he assured the Committee that he will look into the matter and take appropriate action. It is also further brought to the notice of the Committee that unauthorised hawkers are taken out of Tirumala by midnight and left in interior Bakrapeta forest area. Even in this process also, mainly Hindus are targeted and Muslims are rarely touched.
Opposite to Lepakshi Emporium, there are about 50 Nepali shopkeepers who are Christians and they also offer prayers on Sundays, reading the Bible and other Christian religious material in Tirumala.
About 40 Muslim shopkeepers also are there in Tirumala. They offer namaz on Fridays in Tirumala. There are also some Muslim hawkers mostly from Kadiri (Ananthapur District).
Dress code and putting tilakam
Even though the EO has stated that dress code and tilakam were prescribed for the employees, these were not being strictly implemented. The Committee impressed upon the EO to implement these strictly.
Other illegal activities in Tirumala
The Committee was informed that various illegal activities both at Tirumala and at Tirupathi are going on, such as sale and consumption of liquor, sale and consumption of meat, flesh trade, gambling etc.
Cow slaughter is taking place in down hill at Tirupathi near D.R. Mahal. The meat is being transported to Tirumala clandestinely.
TTD Kalyana Mandapam at Nagalapuram is being used by the Christians for their prayer congregations and for performance of Christian marriages. Near Sree Rama and Siva Temple in Tirupathi, Christian prayers and propaganda take place by intercepting the Hindu devotees visiting the temples.
The newly constituted Specified Authority in place of the Board of Trustees, (the term of which has expired) is being headed by Shri D. Rosaiah, IAS, who is said to be a Christian.
The Tourism Department is going to take up erection and operation of rope way from Tirupathi to Tirumala. The Tourism Department plans to establish multiplexes, food courts and other entertainment and recreational spots on Tirumala Hills. The Committee feels that in order to facilitate the activities of Tourism Department on the hills, the area of TTD is restricted to two hills covering an area of 27.5 sq.kms.
Division Bench of Andhra Pradesh High Court has observed in a judgment as follows: ?Although there is no documentation available as the origin is lost in antiquity, there is no attempt made before us to question the ownership of the Lord Venkateswara of Seven Hills. This being true and a real concept, the Board of Trustees, the Committee or the Executive Officer are only administrators of the property of Lord Venkateswara. They can have no right of ownership in themselves and they cannot thus decide to do anything against the interest of the right of the owner i.e., in the instant case, Lord Venkateswara. Once the ownership is resolved and the right to administer is deemed to vest as provided under Article 26 of the Constitution of India in the plurality of the devotees and regulated by the provisions of the Act and Rules framed thereunder, no administrator, whether appointed under the Act or otherwise can take liberty to destroy the sanctity and holiness of the Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanams and domain, as we have already held, extends to all the Seven Hills called ?Tirumala?.?
Earlier the Division Bench in para 3 held as follows:- ?It is not in dispute that pilgrims in thousands and millions in number sometimes visit the temple and there is no day which is not full of activities of the pilgrims and various rituals, poojas and rites of the cult preserved since antiquity and no part of the Seven Hills, except some secular activities which are essential for the service of Lord Venkateswara, is free from religious activities in and around the temple right from the Foot Hills on all sides.?
The Sacred Seven Hills
The Committee is of the considered opinion that restricting the area of TTD to only 21 kms covering two hills, runs counter to the ancient texts and age-old traditions and practices of the temple and that the Hindus always considered Sri Venkateswara as Lord of the Seven Hills and lakhs of devotees climb the Seven Hills with utmost devotion and reverence bare footed chanting the names of Lord Venkateswara. The Committee further feels that opening the Seven Hills to the Tourism Department will destroy the sanctity, serenity and spirituality of the Seven Hills and will seriously hurt the feelings of the Hindus throughout the country and the world.
Funds of the TTD
Previously Hindu Dharma Parirakshana Samithi was organizsing various activities like Harikathas, devotional lectures and concerts in religious music and dance by eminent artists. Now, the name Hindu has been removed and a Dharma Prachara Parishad is in its place which hardly conducts any religious discourses by eminent Hindu spiritual leaders and does not conduct any religious cultural activities by prominent artists. The members of the public further expressed that eminent Hindu spiritual leaders should be invited to give discourses regularly at important places throughout the country and even abroad. They are of the further opinion that contributions of the devotees running into hundreds of crores should be utilised only for Hindu religious and dharmic activities and various service activities in the name of Lord Venkateswara only. The funds should not be diverted to other activities.
The Devasthanam has donated considerable land to a Muslim organisation for construction of a mosque, which has seriously hurt and agitated Hindus, arousing their religious sentiments. Several persons have expressed that more than 35,000 temples in the state are not having any means for performing daily poojas and donating for other religions is wholly unwarranted.
Constitution of TTD Board and the Committee
It is the general view of the public that TTD Board and its Committees should comprise of eminent devout Hindus who have contributed to the development of the Hindu faith and spirituality and government of the day should take the advice of the Hindu dharmacharyas and Hindu spiritual leaders in making such appointments.
Planned attempt in Tirupathi by evangelists to defile the great holy shrine
Startling revelation by the fact-finding committee Congress patronage suspected
From Our Special Correspondent
His Holiness Sri Vishwesha Teertha of Pejawar Mutt, Udipi, requested Justice G. Bikshapathy, Justice K.B. Siddappa, former Judges of Andhra Pradesh High Court, Shri T.S. Rao, former Director General of Police, Andhra Pradesh, Dr. P. Geervani, former Vice-Chancellor of Padmavathi Mahila Vishwavidyalaya and Dr R. Srihari, former Vice-Chancellor of Dravidian University, Kuppam, to function as a fact-finding committee under the chairmanship of Justice G. Bikshapathy to ascertain the factual position as regards the activities of non-Hindu religious communities in Tirumala and Tirupathi.
Many people from Christian and Muslim communities were being employed in the TTD and some of the Hindu employees were even converted as Christians and they practice Christianity. About 40 families in Balaji Colony are Christians. They hold congregations and prayers on Sundays.
Only Hindus are to be appointed as employees in the TTD under the rule. However, the EO stated that for some period this was not followed with the result that some Muslim personnel came to be appointed. He further stated that steps are being taken to shift them to some other places gradually. Some employees in the TTD also profess Christianity and that in the police quarters also congregations and prayers are conducted regularly.
Discontinued the practice of garlanding the portraits of Lord Venkateswara and Goddess Padmavathi everyday. Instead she kept a portrait of Jesus Christ and the Cross on her office table. She sends batches of students in the university buses to the church. It is also stated that in the Mahila University, the students are not allowed to have tilak on the forehead now-a-days and that students putting tilak are being discriminated.
Cow slaughter is taking place in down hill at Tirupathi near D.R. Mahal. The meat is being transported to Tirumala clandestinely. TTD Kalyana Mandapam at Nagalapuram is being used by the Christians for their prayer congregations and for performance of Christian marriages. Near Sree Rama and Siva Temple in Tirupathi, Christian prayers and propaganda take place by intercepting the Hindu devotees visiting the temples.
Sri Vishwesha Teertha Swamiji of the Pejawar Mutt in response to startling disclosures of the planned evangelist activities in the holy Tirupathi temple premises announced that the leaders of Hindu mutts would meet in the temple complex on July 15 to discuss the activities of Christian missionaries, including attempts to convert Hindus in Tirumala and Tirupathi.
The Swami said it was disturbing that Christian missionaries had selected these places to carry out conversions. ?We will meet in Hyderabad on July 11 and then in Tirupathi on July 15 to chalk out our course of action,? he said. He was speaking after receiving a report from a fact-finding committee on this issue and sent by him to Tirupathi. The committee visited Tirumala and Tirupathi last month and held meetings with people there before preparing the report.
?As a Hindu saint, I am worried about the conversion activity taking place there, which was why I constituted the committee to look into the matter,? he said.
Shri D. Bheemasena Rao, the convenor of the Tirumala Tirupathi Samrakshana Samiti, said the July 15 meeting is likely to chalk out a mass awareness programme against conversion. Retired Andhra Pradesh Director General of Police, Shri T.S. Rao, who was a member of the fact-finding committee, said that 15 to 20 families in Tirumala have been converted in the past two years. He alleged that the vice-chancellors of the Padmavathi and Venkateshwara universities were using coercive methods to convert students to Christianity. ?During public interactions, we were told that students who had enrolled for PhDs were being pressurised to convert. They have even been told that they would not get their doctorate unless they converted,? he added.
Dravida University?s former Vice-Chancellor Dr R. Srihari maintained that Christian missionaries had chosen some important places of worship in Andhra Pradesh as part of their strategy, which was why they had moved to Tirumala and Tirupathi for this exercise.
The following is the full text of the high-level committee?s report:
The Committee found that members of the Christian community distributed religious pamphlets and copies of the Bible to the students who were returning after writing the EAMCET examinations conducted at various centres in Tirupathi in May 2006. Apart from other persons, who deposed before the Committee, this information was also disclosed by the son of Shri Prabhakara Acharya, Secretary of Vaikhanasa Ashram at Tirumala, who appeared for the EAMCET examinations. This activity of the Christians led to serious tense situation in Tirupathi. It was also revealed to the Committee that a large number of women and men, dividing themselves into several groups, distributed Christian religious material at various places including EAMCET centres. Some student organisations protested against these activities. Police had to intervene to maintain law and order.
On April 9, 2006, two Christians by name Balaraju (pastor) and Babu while coming down from Tirumala to Tirupathi in bus bearing No. AP 11Z 1130 distributed pamphlets propagating Christianity to the pilgrims travelling in that bus. One of the passengers Shri Arvind of Hyderabad complained the matter to the AV&SO Shri S. Sivananda Kishore, who after enquiry, gave a report on 11.4.2006 to the Vigilance and Security Officer, TTD. Basing on his report, a case in crime No. 8/2006 was registered against S. Balaraju and P. Babu, residents of Tirupathi and the police took up investigation. On the basis of the said complaint, Shri R. Sivananda Kishore (AV&SO, Sector-III, TTD, Tirumala), in his report recommended as follows:
?In the light of instant case, the following recommendations may be considered to avoid recurrence of such incidents in future.
As per Rule 197 of APCHR and E Act 1987 the population living in Tirumala shall adhere to the norms and shall follow the sentiments of Hindu Religion. As such a thorough probe has to be taken up to verify the antecedents of non-Hindu employees who are working in TTD as well as government departments, i.e. police, fire services, commercial taxes, etc., who are staying in Tirumala. The identified employees and their families shall be shifted from Tirumala.
His Holiness Sri Vishwesha Teertha of Pejawar Mutt, Udipi, requested Justice G. Bikshapathy, Justice K.B. Siddappa, former Judges of Andhra Pradesh High Court, Shri T.S. Rao, former Director General of Police, Andhra Pradesh, Dr. P. Geervani, former Vice-Chancellor of Padmavathi Mahila Vishwavidyalaya and Dr. R. Srihari, former Vice-Chancellor of Dravidian University, Kuppam, to function as a fact-finding committee under the chairmanship of Justice G. Bikshapathy to ascertain the factual position as regards the activities of non-Hindu religious communities in Tirumala and Tirupathi and to furnish a report to His Holiness for considering the steps to be taken to prevent undesirable activities of the Christian and other non-Hindu communities.
Some of the family members of the TTD employees such as wife and children are practicing Christian ideology and inviting the pastors to conduct prayers in their homes at Tirumala, the committee found.
In the Rule 198 of APCHR&E Act 1987 the following activities are prohibited at Tirumala:-
(A) Carrying and possession of holy books of other religions like Bible, Quran etc. (B) Any kind of propagation of other than Hindu religion by way of distribution of pamphlets, literature, brochures, stickers, banners, flags, including prayers and speeches etc.
Two Christian women belonging to Chilakuluripet were found in the TTD queue complex and they were caught red-handed on 26.4.2006 distributing religious pamphlets to the pilgrims in the queue and were handed over to the Deputy Superintendent of Police at Tirumala by the pilgrims themselves. The Committee was informed that the Vigilance personnel took into custody these two Christian women and produced them before the DSP, Tirumala. The Committee was told that the Special Officer got released those two women after questioning them and arranged special darshan and gave prasadam. When the Committee met the Executive Officer on 22.06.2006, Special Officer Shri Dharma Reddy was present and he told the Committee that those two women came from an old-age home, run by a Christian mission and they stated that as per the wish of some of the inmates of the old-age home who were suffering from AIDS, they came to get prasadam for distributing it to those inmates, and on that representation of the two women, he permitted them to have darshan after signing the requisite declaration and gave them prasadam. No name of the old-age home was disclosed.
It is highly unlikely that a Christian would travel long distance to visit Tirumala to collect prasadam offered by a Hindu religious temple to be given to the inmates of an old-age home run by a Christian mission. The two women did not disclose to the TTD officials concerned before entering the queue complex that they were Christians, and they got into the queue complex without signing the requisite declaration and obtaining permission of the TTD officials concerned.
Two Christians David (pastor) and Kumar were found propagating Christianity in Tirumala and they were handed over to police. The police registered a case and kept them for two days on remand. Those two persons admitted that they committed a mistake. This was also confirmed by the EO, TTD who stated that the two were indulging in religious propaganda. However, strangely the Special Officer, Shri Dharma Reddy, stated that they did not indulge in any Christian propaganda. The two Christians were eventually released without taking any action against them.
On May 21, 2006, Special Officer Shri Dharma Reddy held a press conference in which he stated that no Christian religious propaganda was going on in Tirumala. It is evident that he is not taking a serious view of these objectionable activities of the Christians at the holy place of Tirumala.
Propagation of Christian religion in educational institutions in Tirupathi
Educational institutions at Tirupathi were established on TTD land and with TTD funds. But in the colleges and hostel at Tirupathi, Christian religious propagation is rampant. The Christian students themselves act as propagators. Shri Deva Sangeetham, Principal of S.V. University College, openly indulges in propagating and converting the students to Christianity by making them go to Church, reading the Bible and creating disaffection towards Hindu religion. After Shri Deva Sangeetham has taken charge as Principal, the practice of garlanding the portrait of Lord Venkateswara is stopped.
After Smt. Veena Noble Das took charge as Vice-Chancellor of Padmavathi Mahila University, she got removed the photos of Lord Venkateswara and Goddess Padmavathi from all the institutions of the Mahila University and she also got removed the portrait of Lord Venkateswara from her office and discontinued the practice of garlanding the portraits of Lord Venkateswara and Goddess Padmavathi everyday. Instead she kept a portrait of Jesus Christ and the Cross on her office table. She sends batches of students in the university buses to the church. It is also stated that in the Mahila University, the students are not allowed to have tilak on the forehead now-a-days and that students putting tilak are being discriminated.
Employment in the TTD
Only Hindus are to be appointed as employees in the TTD under the rule. However, the EO stated that for some period this was not followed with the result that some Muslim personnel came to be appointed. He further stated that steps are being taken to shift them to some other places gradually. Some employees in the TTD profess Christianity and that in the police quarters also congregations and prayers are conducted regularly. There are about 40 Christian families residing in Tirumala and they hold religious congregations at their homes on Sundays. It is stated that even in the Annadanam Complex there is an employee, Shri Ananda Raju belonging to Christian community, working as Superintendent. The EO has stated that he will enquire and take action. Another Christian woman works in the electrical department. Gopinath, Garden Superintendent, also belongs to Christian community.
Non-Hindu employees of TTD and their activities
It is brought to the notice of the Committee that many people from Christian and Muslim communities were being employed in the TTD and some of the Hindu employees were even converted as Christians and they practice Christianity. About 40 families in Balaji Colony are Christians. They hold congregations and prayers on Sundays.
The Committee was informed that Gopinath, who was posted on deputation as Garden Superintendent, is a Christian and that he criticises worshipping Lord Venkateswara saying why should a black stone be decorated with garlands, and that he indulges in criticising Hindu Religion.
Considering the above facts and circumstances, the propagation of Christianity with an ulterior motive of conversion is taking place in Tirupathi and Tirumala. Since the EO has categorically assured the Committee that no such incidents will be allowed to take place, the matter has to be reviewed periodically.
Scouts and guides
In the queue complex number of scouts and guides are deployed to regulate the pilgrims. It is understood that details of the religion of the persons who are so engaged is not verified and that some of them belong to non-Hindu communities. The scouts and guides are allowed into the main temple and to have darshan. The Executive Officer has informed the Committee that he would take appropriate measures to prevent non-Hindus being deployed as scouts and guides in Tirumala.
Hawkers and shopkeepers
There are number of hawkers who belong to Muslim community. Two instances are given. Shop Nos. 192 and 72 in the shopping complex are run by Shri Jamal Khadar and Maithri. When this was brought to the notice of EO he assured the Committee that he will look into the matter and take appropriate action. It is also further brought to the notice of the Committee that unauthorised hawkers are taken out of Tirumala by midnight and left in interior Bakrapeta forest area. Even in this process also, mainly Hindus are targeted and Muslims are rarely touched.
Opposite to Lepakshi Emporium, there are about 50 Nepali shopkeepers who are Christians and they also offer prayers on Sundays, reading the Bible and other Christian religious material in Tirumala.
About 40 Muslim shopkeepers also are there in Tirumala. They offer namaz on Fridays in Tirumala. There are also some Muslim hawkers mostly from Kadiri (Ananthapur District).
Dress code and putting tilakam
Even though the EO has stated that dress code and tilakam were prescribed for the employees, these were not being strictly implemented. The Committee impressed upon the EO to implement these strictly.
Other illegal activities in Tirumala
The Committee was informed that various illegal activities both at Tirumala and at Tirupathi are going on, such as sale and consumption of liquor, sale and consumption of meat, flesh trade, gambling etc.
Cow slaughter is taking place in down hill at Tirupathi near D.R. Mahal. The meat is being transported to Tirumala clandestinely.
TTD Kalyana Mandapam at Nagalapuram is being used by the Christians for their prayer congregations and for performance of Christian marriages. Near Sree Rama and Siva Temple in Tirupathi, Christian prayers and propaganda take place by intercepting the Hindu devotees visiting the temples.
The newly constituted Specified Authority in place of the Board of Trustees, (the term of which has expired) is being headed by Shri D. Rosaiah, IAS, who is said to be a Christian.
The Tourism Department is going to take up erection and operation of rope way from Tirupathi to Tirumala. The Tourism Department plans to establish multiplexes, food courts and other entertainment and recreational spots on Tirumala Hills. The Committee feels that in order to facilitate the activities of Tourism Department on the hills, the area of TTD is restricted to two hills covering an area of 27.5 sq.kms.
Division Bench of Andhra Pradesh High Court has observed in a judgment as follows: ?Although there is no documentation available as the origin is lost in antiquity, there is no attempt made before us to question the ownership of the Lord Venkateswara of Seven Hills. This being true and a real concept, the Board of Trustees, the Committee or the Executive Officer are only administrators of the property of Lord Venkateswara. They can have no right of ownership in themselves and they cannot thus decide to do anything against the interest of the right of the owner i.e., in the instant case, Lord Venkateswara. Once the ownership is resolved and the right to administer is deemed to vest as provided under Article 26 of the Constitution of India in the plurality of the devotees and regulated by the provisions of the Act and Rules framed thereunder, no administrator, whether appointed under the Act or otherwise can take liberty to destroy the sanctity and holiness of the Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanams and domain, as we have already held, extends to all the Seven Hills called ?Tirumala?.?
Earlier the Division Bench in para 3 held as follows:- ?It is not in dispute that pilgrims in thousands and millions in number sometimes visit the temple and there is no day which is not full of activities of the pilgrims and various rituals, poojas and rites of the cult preserved since antiquity and no part of the Seven Hills, except some secular activities which are essential for the service of Lord Venkateswara, is free from religious activities in and around the temple right from the Foot Hills on all sides.?
The Sacred Seven Hills
The Committee is of the considered opinion that restricting the area of TTD to only 21 kms covering two hills, runs counter to the ancient texts and age-old traditions and practices of the temple and that the Hindus always considered Sri Venkateswara as Lord of the Seven Hills and lakhs of devotees climb the Seven Hills with utmost devotion and reverence bare footed chanting the names of Lord Venkateswara. The Committee further feels that opening the Seven Hills to the Tourism Department will destroy the sanctity, serenity and spirituality of the Seven Hills and will seriously hurt the feelings of the Hindus throughout the country and the world.
Funds of the TTD
Previously Hindu Dharma Parirakshana Samithi was organizsing various activities like Harikathas, devotional lectures and concerts in religious music and dance by eminent artists. Now, the name Hindu has been removed and a Dharma Prachara Parishad is in its place which hardly conducts any religious discourses by eminent Hindu spiritual leaders and does not conduct any religious cultural activities by prominent artists. The members of the public further expressed that eminent Hindu spiritual leaders should be invited to give discourses regularly at important places throughout the country and even abroad. They are of the further opinion that contributions of the devotees running into hundreds of crores should be utilised only for Hindu religious and dharmic activities and various service activities in the name of Lord Venkateswara only. The funds should not be diverted to other activities.
The Devasthanam has donated considerable land to a Muslim organisation for construction of a mosque, which has seriously hurt and agitated Hindus, arousing their religious sentiments. Several persons have expressed that more than 35,000 temples in the state are not having any means for performing daily poojas and donating for other religions is wholly unwarranted.
Constitution of TTD Board and the Committee
It is the general view of the public that TTD Board and its Committees should comprise of eminent devout Hindus who have contributed to the development of the Hindu faith and spirituality and government of the day should take the advice of the Hindu dharmacharyas and Hindu spiritual leaders in making such appointments.
Labels:
2010,
Christianity,
Church,
Communist,
Comonwealth Games,
Hindu,
India,
New Delhi
The plight of the converted dalits
Organiser,2007 Issues > April 22, 2007
Controversy
The plight of the converted dalits
Equality is a Hindu heritage. Others only profess
By Shachi Rairikar
The most important factor that desisted Dr. Ambedkar from converting to Christianity or Islam was that both these religions were foreign, born outside of the Hindu civilization. Adopting these religions would de-Indianise the dalits, which would be against the national interest.
For decades dalits have been converting to Christianity or Islam in the vain hope of being liberated from their dalit status. The proselytising forces of these foreign faiths market their religions as not recognising the caste system and giving equal status to all. Only after conversion do the dalits realise the fraud that has been perpetuated on them in the name of equality when they find discriminatory treatment in Christian and Muslim societies and even their places of worship.
And this is not a new phenomenon. Many decades ago Dr. Ambedkar had studied the plight of dalits converted to Christianity and observed, ?Indian Christians like all other Indians are divided by race, by language, and by caste. Their religion has not been a sufficiently strong unifying force as to make difference of language, race and caste as though they were mere distinctions.? The same was the case with the Muslim converts. He said, ?Everybody infers that Islam must be free from slavery and caste. (While slavery existed), much of its support was derived from Islam and Islamic countries. While the prescriptions by the Prophet regarding the just and humane treatment of slaves contained in the Koran are praiseworthy, there is nothing whatever in Islam that lends support to the abolition of this curse. But if slavery has gone, caste among Muslims has remained.?
Dr. Ambedkar?s conversion to Buddhism was his way of revolting against the caste system in Hinduism. When he announced his intention to convert to another religion in 1935 many Christian and Muslim leaders and organisations tried to lure him into their religions. To those people he said, ?We are fully conscious of the fact that go anywhere we will, we would have to fight for our welfare if we took to Christianity or Islam.?
For 20 years he studied all the alternative religions for the purpose of conversion. Christianity did not satisfy the criteria laid down by him for determining a true religion. About Islam he wrote, ?The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity.? He was of the opinion that ?Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin.?
But the most important factor that desisted Dr. Ambedkar from converting to Christianity or Islam was that both these religions were foreign, born outside of the Hindu civilization. Adopting these religions would de-Indianise the dalits, which would be against the national interest. He wrote, ?If the depressed classes join Islam or Christianity, they not only go out of the Hindu religion, but they also go out of the Hindu culture. What the consequences of conversion will do to the country as a whole is well worth bearing in mind.? So after the detailed study and great introspection, he chose Buddhism, an offshoot of Hinduism. The Dalai Lama has considered Buddhism a part of Hinduism. He has said: ?When I say that Buddhism is part of Hinduism, certain people criticise me. But if I were to say that Hinduism and Buddhism are totally different, it would not be in conformity with truth.?
Dr. Ambedkar himself perceived Buddhism as a part of the larger Hindu family. When he introduced the Hindu Code Bill in Parliament, he included the Buddhists, the Jains and the Sikhs in the Hindu fold. On being questioned for doing so, Dr. Ambedkar replied, ?The application of the Hindu Code to Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains was a historical development and it would be too late, sociologically, to object to it. When the Buddha differed from the Vedic Brahmins, he did so only in matters of creed, but left the Hindu legal framework intact. He did not propound a separate law for his followers. The same was the case with Mahavir and the ten Sikh gurus.?
The Christian and Muslim proselytisers have no interest in the welfare of the dalits or the integrity of the nation. Had their concern been genuine they wouldn?t have permitted the caste discriminations to be carried over to the church or mosques. All they are interested into winning converts and increasing their numbers. The dalits are the soft targets whose impoverished conditions are exploited to change their religion. Pope John Paul II had exhorted the bishops to target the dalits for conversion. He had said, ?At all times, you must continue to make certain that special attention is given to those belonging to the lowest castes, especially the dalits.? It is common to see the different Christian and Muslim religious organisations boasting of the number of converts they had obtained and competing amongst themselves as to which religion has the largest number of followers. For them, it is just a number game.
The demand for reservation for dalit Christians or Muslims arises not out of sympathy for the depressed classes but out of the fact, as confessed by the president and founder of Gospel for Asia K.P. Yohannan, that the denial of affirmative-action benefits for dalit Christians and Muslims is ?a huge, huge roadblock for masses of communities to embrace the Christian faith.? Reservations and privileges for dalit Christians and Muslims will only strengthen the dubious designs of the proselytizing forces that are using dalits for furthering their goals. Dalits converted on the false promise of equal status in a casteless society, must be reconverted to Hinduism. The dalit icon Babu Jagjivan Ram had said, ??we oppose the way in which conversions are done. Therefore, we have to reconvert those who might have been converted by deceit or under some temptation.?
R. Thirumalvalavan, leader of the Dalit Panthers Party of India, said, ?For emancipation of dalits, conversion is not the solution.? The solution lies in the comprehension and adoption of the real essence of Hinduism by all the Hindus, irrespective of their caste.
Hinduism perceives divinity in everything, whether living or non-living. One of Adi Shankaracharya?s finest poems, Manisha Panchakam, was inspired by his dialogue with a chandala, a member of the lowest caste. Once, when Shankara was on his way to the temple after a bath in the Ganga, he found a chandala with four dogs blocking his path. He got furious when the chandala refused to step aside, and asked him to do so. The chandala asked, ?If there is only one existence, what is it that you want to drive away: My body or my soul? If it is my body, both your and mine are made up of the same physical elements. But if it is my soul, it is also no different from yours. How can therefore be any distinctions of caste and creed?? Filled with remorse, Shankara prostrated himself before the chandala, thinking: ?He who has learnt to see one existence everywhere, he is my master?be he a Brahmin or a chandala.?
The need of the hour is a collective effort of all sections of the Hindu society to reinstate the true spirit of Hinduism. Dalit activist and poet Namdeo Dhasal says, ?Yes, I do feel that the fight to eradicate caste has to be fought by dalits and caste Hindus together carrying forward the tradition of Adi Shankara, which got broken somewhere in between.?
Controversy
The plight of the converted dalits
Equality is a Hindu heritage. Others only profess
By Shachi Rairikar
The most important factor that desisted Dr. Ambedkar from converting to Christianity or Islam was that both these religions were foreign, born outside of the Hindu civilization. Adopting these religions would de-Indianise the dalits, which would be against the national interest.
For decades dalits have been converting to Christianity or Islam in the vain hope of being liberated from their dalit status. The proselytising forces of these foreign faiths market their religions as not recognising the caste system and giving equal status to all. Only after conversion do the dalits realise the fraud that has been perpetuated on them in the name of equality when they find discriminatory treatment in Christian and Muslim societies and even their places of worship.
And this is not a new phenomenon. Many decades ago Dr. Ambedkar had studied the plight of dalits converted to Christianity and observed, ?Indian Christians like all other Indians are divided by race, by language, and by caste. Their religion has not been a sufficiently strong unifying force as to make difference of language, race and caste as though they were mere distinctions.? The same was the case with the Muslim converts. He said, ?Everybody infers that Islam must be free from slavery and caste. (While slavery existed), much of its support was derived from Islam and Islamic countries. While the prescriptions by the Prophet regarding the just and humane treatment of slaves contained in the Koran are praiseworthy, there is nothing whatever in Islam that lends support to the abolition of this curse. But if slavery has gone, caste among Muslims has remained.?
Dr. Ambedkar?s conversion to Buddhism was his way of revolting against the caste system in Hinduism. When he announced his intention to convert to another religion in 1935 many Christian and Muslim leaders and organisations tried to lure him into their religions. To those people he said, ?We are fully conscious of the fact that go anywhere we will, we would have to fight for our welfare if we took to Christianity or Islam.?
For 20 years he studied all the alternative religions for the purpose of conversion. Christianity did not satisfy the criteria laid down by him for determining a true religion. About Islam he wrote, ?The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity.? He was of the opinion that ?Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin.?
But the most important factor that desisted Dr. Ambedkar from converting to Christianity or Islam was that both these religions were foreign, born outside of the Hindu civilization. Adopting these religions would de-Indianise the dalits, which would be against the national interest. He wrote, ?If the depressed classes join Islam or Christianity, they not only go out of the Hindu religion, but they also go out of the Hindu culture. What the consequences of conversion will do to the country as a whole is well worth bearing in mind.? So after the detailed study and great introspection, he chose Buddhism, an offshoot of Hinduism. The Dalai Lama has considered Buddhism a part of Hinduism. He has said: ?When I say that Buddhism is part of Hinduism, certain people criticise me. But if I were to say that Hinduism and Buddhism are totally different, it would not be in conformity with truth.?
Dr. Ambedkar himself perceived Buddhism as a part of the larger Hindu family. When he introduced the Hindu Code Bill in Parliament, he included the Buddhists, the Jains and the Sikhs in the Hindu fold. On being questioned for doing so, Dr. Ambedkar replied, ?The application of the Hindu Code to Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains was a historical development and it would be too late, sociologically, to object to it. When the Buddha differed from the Vedic Brahmins, he did so only in matters of creed, but left the Hindu legal framework intact. He did not propound a separate law for his followers. The same was the case with Mahavir and the ten Sikh gurus.?
The Christian and Muslim proselytisers have no interest in the welfare of the dalits or the integrity of the nation. Had their concern been genuine they wouldn?t have permitted the caste discriminations to be carried over to the church or mosques. All they are interested into winning converts and increasing their numbers. The dalits are the soft targets whose impoverished conditions are exploited to change their religion. Pope John Paul II had exhorted the bishops to target the dalits for conversion. He had said, ?At all times, you must continue to make certain that special attention is given to those belonging to the lowest castes, especially the dalits.? It is common to see the different Christian and Muslim religious organisations boasting of the number of converts they had obtained and competing amongst themselves as to which religion has the largest number of followers. For them, it is just a number game.
The demand for reservation for dalit Christians or Muslims arises not out of sympathy for the depressed classes but out of the fact, as confessed by the president and founder of Gospel for Asia K.P. Yohannan, that the denial of affirmative-action benefits for dalit Christians and Muslims is ?a huge, huge roadblock for masses of communities to embrace the Christian faith.? Reservations and privileges for dalit Christians and Muslims will only strengthen the dubious designs of the proselytizing forces that are using dalits for furthering their goals. Dalits converted on the false promise of equal status in a casteless society, must be reconverted to Hinduism. The dalit icon Babu Jagjivan Ram had said, ??we oppose the way in which conversions are done. Therefore, we have to reconvert those who might have been converted by deceit or under some temptation.?
R. Thirumalvalavan, leader of the Dalit Panthers Party of India, said, ?For emancipation of dalits, conversion is not the solution.? The solution lies in the comprehension and adoption of the real essence of Hinduism by all the Hindus, irrespective of their caste.
Hinduism perceives divinity in everything, whether living or non-living. One of Adi Shankaracharya?s finest poems, Manisha Panchakam, was inspired by his dialogue with a chandala, a member of the lowest caste. Once, when Shankara was on his way to the temple after a bath in the Ganga, he found a chandala with four dogs blocking his path. He got furious when the chandala refused to step aside, and asked him to do so. The chandala asked, ?If there is only one existence, what is it that you want to drive away: My body or my soul? If it is my body, both your and mine are made up of the same physical elements. But if it is my soul, it is also no different from yours. How can therefore be any distinctions of caste and creed?? Filled with remorse, Shankara prostrated himself before the chandala, thinking: ?He who has learnt to see one existence everywhere, he is my master?be he a Brahmin or a chandala.?
The need of the hour is a collective effort of all sections of the Hindu society to reinstate the true spirit of Hinduism. Dalit activist and poet Namdeo Dhasal says, ?Yes, I do feel that the fight to eradicate caste has to be fought by dalits and caste Hindus together carrying forward the tradition of Adi Shankara, which got broken somewhere in between.?
Labels:
2010,
Christianity,
Church,
Communist,
Comonwealth Games,
Hindu,
India,
New Delhi
Secular governments funding religious visits abroad
Organiser,2009 Issues > September 13 2009
Secular governments funding religious visits abroad
Misappropriation of public money for petty gains
By Himanshu Shekhar Jha
If the money paid by Muslim or Christian tax payers cannot be spent on the pilgrimages undertaken by Hindus, on what legal or moral ground the money paid by Hindu tax payers should be spent on pilgrimages undertaken by Muslims or Christians?
The recent stay of Andhra Pradesh High Court on the State Government’s order providing financial assistance to self-styled Christians for pilgrimage to places connected with the life and teachings of Jesus Christ is a landmark in the history of judicial decisions taken in the past few years in our country.
The Andhra Pradesh Government had reportedly allocated Rs 2,00,00,000/--as airfare subsidy to the Christians in the 2008-09 budget. The arbitrary allocation of fund from public exchequer to individuals for personal tour is prima facie illegal and cannot be justified on any ground whatsoever. What right a Government has to spend public money for the furtherance of a particular faith to which the majority of tax payers owe no allegiance? If the money paid by Muslim or Christian tax payers cannot be spent on the pilgrimages undertaken by Hindus, on what legal or moral ground the money paid by Hindu tax payers should be spent on pilgrimages undertaken by Muslims or Christians?
There is no doubt that the sole motive of the Centre or any State in indulging in such obnoxious deals is to woo the voters belonging to minority communities. It is not that the Centre or the State concerned have suddenly grown very liberal and want to help members of minority communities out of great love for God and mankind. Such grant constitutes a part of the election strategy of the Congress and its allies.
It is significant to note that there is no provision either in the Constitution or in any other law under which airfare or any kind of financial assistance can be given to individuals having separate religion or faith from any public fund. Though the Constitution of India is mainly based on alien legal concepts and contains nothing, which can be called ‘Indian’ in the true sense of the term, even this flawed instrument does not provide for such arbitrary and discriminatory financial aid to individuals for furtherance of their personal faith and religious beliefs. Moreover, it is against the principle of secularism to which the Constitution of India is wedded and which forms part of its basic structure which cannot be dismantled by any whimsical action of the State.
The UPA-led government at the Centre and in states must address the question as to why would they bear travelling and other expenses of individuals when they go on personal tours even if it is connected with religion or faith? More importantly on what legal grounds can the Government pay airfare subsidy to members of a minority community for a pilgrimage when the same is shamelessly denied to those who belong to the majority community for similar purposes?
Another question which is equally important to address is why should the money paid by Hindu tax payers be spent on rituals of non-Hindus against their conscience and will? Is it not flagrant violation of their Fundamental Right to freedom of conscience free profession, practice and propagation of religion guaranteed under Article 25 of the Constitution? If a Muslim and Christian or anyone else belonging to a particular faith or religious denomination would not like their money deposited in state exchequer to be given to Hindus for undertaking pilgrimages to their holy places, whey should Hindu tax payer’s money be lavishly spent on pilgrimages undertaken by those who have no respect for religious beliefs and practices of Hindus? As pointed out earlier, even the Constitution of India does not permit such payments. Take a look at Article 27 of the Constitution which categorically states, "No person shall be compelled to pay any taxes, the proceeds of which are specifically appropriated in payment of expenses for the promotion or maintenance of any particular religion or religious denomination."
Can there be any doubt in the light of the above Constitutional provision that the payment of tax payers’ money to individuals for the promotion or maintenance of their particular religion or faith is arbitrary, illegal and violative of the people’s Fundamental Right to freedom of religion and conscience?
Besides being illegal and unconstitutional the above grants amount to unfair practices within the meaning of the People’s Representations Act. Indiscriminate and arbitrary grant of scholarships to students belonging to minority communities and payment of airfare and other travelling expenses to individuals for Haj and tour of places related to the life and teachings of Jesus Christ are being made from tax payers’ money with the sole and sordid motive of wooing the voters belonging to the communities referred to above. This mischief perpetrated on the people who are already poverty-stricken must be thoroughly exposed by all and brought to an end at the earliest.
A pilgrimage which is performed by ill-gotten money cannot bring desired rewards. The nefarious deal, therefore, deserves to be struck down for good on all counts.
(The writer can be contacted at A-207, Kalyani Apartments, Sector-06, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, (Uttar Pradesh))
Secular governments funding religious visits abroad
Misappropriation of public money for petty gains
By Himanshu Shekhar Jha
If the money paid by Muslim or Christian tax payers cannot be spent on the pilgrimages undertaken by Hindus, on what legal or moral ground the money paid by Hindu tax payers should be spent on pilgrimages undertaken by Muslims or Christians?
The recent stay of Andhra Pradesh High Court on the State Government’s order providing financial assistance to self-styled Christians for pilgrimage to places connected with the life and teachings of Jesus Christ is a landmark in the history of judicial decisions taken in the past few years in our country.
The Andhra Pradesh Government had reportedly allocated Rs 2,00,00,000/--as airfare subsidy to the Christians in the 2008-09 budget. The arbitrary allocation of fund from public exchequer to individuals for personal tour is prima facie illegal and cannot be justified on any ground whatsoever. What right a Government has to spend public money for the furtherance of a particular faith to which the majority of tax payers owe no allegiance? If the money paid by Muslim or Christian tax payers cannot be spent on the pilgrimages undertaken by Hindus, on what legal or moral ground the money paid by Hindu tax payers should be spent on pilgrimages undertaken by Muslims or Christians?
There is no doubt that the sole motive of the Centre or any State in indulging in such obnoxious deals is to woo the voters belonging to minority communities. It is not that the Centre or the State concerned have suddenly grown very liberal and want to help members of minority communities out of great love for God and mankind. Such grant constitutes a part of the election strategy of the Congress and its allies.
It is significant to note that there is no provision either in the Constitution or in any other law under which airfare or any kind of financial assistance can be given to individuals having separate religion or faith from any public fund. Though the Constitution of India is mainly based on alien legal concepts and contains nothing, which can be called ‘Indian’ in the true sense of the term, even this flawed instrument does not provide for such arbitrary and discriminatory financial aid to individuals for furtherance of their personal faith and religious beliefs. Moreover, it is against the principle of secularism to which the Constitution of India is wedded and which forms part of its basic structure which cannot be dismantled by any whimsical action of the State.
The UPA-led government at the Centre and in states must address the question as to why would they bear travelling and other expenses of individuals when they go on personal tours even if it is connected with religion or faith? More importantly on what legal grounds can the Government pay airfare subsidy to members of a minority community for a pilgrimage when the same is shamelessly denied to those who belong to the majority community for similar purposes?
Another question which is equally important to address is why should the money paid by Hindu tax payers be spent on rituals of non-Hindus against their conscience and will? Is it not flagrant violation of their Fundamental Right to freedom of conscience free profession, practice and propagation of religion guaranteed under Article 25 of the Constitution? If a Muslim and Christian or anyone else belonging to a particular faith or religious denomination would not like their money deposited in state exchequer to be given to Hindus for undertaking pilgrimages to their holy places, whey should Hindu tax payer’s money be lavishly spent on pilgrimages undertaken by those who have no respect for religious beliefs and practices of Hindus? As pointed out earlier, even the Constitution of India does not permit such payments. Take a look at Article 27 of the Constitution which categorically states, "No person shall be compelled to pay any taxes, the proceeds of which are specifically appropriated in payment of expenses for the promotion or maintenance of any particular religion or religious denomination."
Can there be any doubt in the light of the above Constitutional provision that the payment of tax payers’ money to individuals for the promotion or maintenance of their particular religion or faith is arbitrary, illegal and violative of the people’s Fundamental Right to freedom of religion and conscience?
Besides being illegal and unconstitutional the above grants amount to unfair practices within the meaning of the People’s Representations Act. Indiscriminate and arbitrary grant of scholarships to students belonging to minority communities and payment of airfare and other travelling expenses to individuals for Haj and tour of places related to the life and teachings of Jesus Christ are being made from tax payers’ money with the sole and sordid motive of wooing the voters belonging to the communities referred to above. This mischief perpetrated on the people who are already poverty-stricken must be thoroughly exposed by all and brought to an end at the earliest.
A pilgrimage which is performed by ill-gotten money cannot bring desired rewards. The nefarious deal, therefore, deserves to be struck down for good on all counts.
(The writer can be contacted at A-207, Kalyani Apartments, Sector-06, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, (Uttar Pradesh))
Labels:
2010,
Christianity,
Church,
Communist,
Comonwealth Games,
Hindu,
India,
New Delhi
Congressmen oppose Margaret Alva’s appointment
Organiser,2009 Issues > August 23, 2009
Congressmen oppose Margaret Alva’s appointment
Sonia’s ploy to Christianise Uttarakhand?
By Pramod Kumar
Is there a conspiracy of Christianisation of Uttarakhand behind the appointment of "Christian activist Smt Margaret Alva" as Governor of Uttarakhand? At least a section of Congress Hindu leaders sees a sinister conspiracy behind this appointment. In a memorandum presented to Congress Disciplinary Committee chairman Shri AK Antony under the banner of Congress Secular Hindu Forum (CSHF), they demanded immediate replacement of Smt. Alva from Uttarakhand Governorship. Smt Alva was appointed Governor of Uttarakhand on July 18.
The Congress Hindu Forum general secretary K Ravi Kumar in his memorandum threatened to launch a strong agitation against the party leadership if their demand was not met. "If Congress leadership denies our demand, we will be left with no other alternative but to turn to a strong agitation against Congress leadership with the support of all like-minded Hindu Congress people. We can co-ordinate with other organisations also for the success of our movement. No doubt that the entire Hindu population will get together to protest against the Congress leadership," the memorandum warns. They wondered how Smt. Alva, who had been removed from all responsibilities of Congress High Command, by Smt. Sonia Gandhi herself during the Karnataka Assembly elections, was appointed Governor of Uttarakhand.
The Forum appealed to Shri Antony to bring this issue to the notice of Smt. Sonia Gandhi and advise her to settle the issue amicably, which is acceptable to all sections of Congress workers. "We hope the Congress Disciplinary Committee will understand the gravity of the situation and will take suitable measures to avoid such unpleasant agitations, which may embarrass the party leadership, for which we should not be held liable," Ravi Kumar added.
"The Himalayas is the holy land of Hindu believers in the world and the divine centres such as Haridwar, Rishikesh, Badrinath, Kedarnath, Uttarkashi, Karna Prayag, Rudra Prayag, Gangotri, Yamunotri, Alaknanda and some divine rivers are situated in the same land of Uttarakhand. So, it is a bounden duty and obligation of the Union Government to secure this holy land in its own atmosphere, culture and system. Smt. Margaret Alva is a Christian activist, gnostic and fervent for a Christian domination within the Congress Party. So, the Hindu believers, who are traditional voters of Indian National Congress analyse that there will be a sure chance for Christian conversions and other Christian promotional activities such as transferring the Government land for constructing churches or Prayer Halls to the Missionaries with the blessings of Smt. Margaret Alva," the memorandum, dated July 27, alleged. A copy of the memorandum is with Organiser.
The memorandum found it absolutely a paradox that a Christian activist was appointed Governor to the state, which is considered a holy land of Hindu believers all over the world. "It is almost similar to a virtual ordination of a Bishop at the supreme seat of Jagadguru Shankaracharya. It is not agreeable before the conscience of the devotees," the memorandum said.
"The Hindu believers in the Congress Party suspect that an attempt is going on for the Christianisation of holy places in Uttarakhand, transformation of Hindustan into Christianisthan. It is also suspected that all these hidden agendas were planned in advance with the knowledge of Smt. Soniaji. Christianisation is now a visible reality and Christian domination within the Congress Party as well as in other states is a fact by secluding the Hindu-Congress people from their eligible position. The question of Governorship of Uttarakhand is a relevant and fitting example of tactic and silent underplay against the Hindu followers of the Congress Party," the memorandum further said.
"The Hindu-Congress people have a legacy, historicity and patriotism from the ages. It is not fair to betray their pride and dignity. But as a matter of fact Smt. Soniaji is knowingly or unknowingly taking a special interest to avoid the dignity of the Hindu Congress majority by unduly promoting the minority religious sects for the last ten years.
"We have noticed that certain decisions and activities of Congress leadership are even against the relevance of our great Indian Freedom Movement. It is the irony of fate that the same Congress Party, which fought for freedom from British Colonialist, surrenders our prides and privileges before the American Colonialism.
"We suspect that there might be a conspiracy in appointing Smt. Margaret Alva as the Governor of Uttarakhand. The Hindu believers in Congress Party consider that even Vatican and Indian Ecclesial hierarchy could have been involved... If the Congress Party gets majority to form a Government, there will be a wide Christianisation everywhere in that state with the tactical support of Smt. Alva within a span of five years. We have reason to believe this is one of the hidden agendas of that Governorship," the memorandum said.
Congressmen oppose Margaret Alva’s appointment
Sonia’s ploy to Christianise Uttarakhand?
By Pramod Kumar
Is there a conspiracy of Christianisation of Uttarakhand behind the appointment of "Christian activist Smt Margaret Alva" as Governor of Uttarakhand? At least a section of Congress Hindu leaders sees a sinister conspiracy behind this appointment. In a memorandum presented to Congress Disciplinary Committee chairman Shri AK Antony under the banner of Congress Secular Hindu Forum (CSHF), they demanded immediate replacement of Smt. Alva from Uttarakhand Governorship. Smt Alva was appointed Governor of Uttarakhand on July 18.
The Congress Hindu Forum general secretary K Ravi Kumar in his memorandum threatened to launch a strong agitation against the party leadership if their demand was not met. "If Congress leadership denies our demand, we will be left with no other alternative but to turn to a strong agitation against Congress leadership with the support of all like-minded Hindu Congress people. We can co-ordinate with other organisations also for the success of our movement. No doubt that the entire Hindu population will get together to protest against the Congress leadership," the memorandum warns. They wondered how Smt. Alva, who had been removed from all responsibilities of Congress High Command, by Smt. Sonia Gandhi herself during the Karnataka Assembly elections, was appointed Governor of Uttarakhand.
The Forum appealed to Shri Antony to bring this issue to the notice of Smt. Sonia Gandhi and advise her to settle the issue amicably, which is acceptable to all sections of Congress workers. "We hope the Congress Disciplinary Committee will understand the gravity of the situation and will take suitable measures to avoid such unpleasant agitations, which may embarrass the party leadership, for which we should not be held liable," Ravi Kumar added.
"The Himalayas is the holy land of Hindu believers in the world and the divine centres such as Haridwar, Rishikesh, Badrinath, Kedarnath, Uttarkashi, Karna Prayag, Rudra Prayag, Gangotri, Yamunotri, Alaknanda and some divine rivers are situated in the same land of Uttarakhand. So, it is a bounden duty and obligation of the Union Government to secure this holy land in its own atmosphere, culture and system. Smt. Margaret Alva is a Christian activist, gnostic and fervent for a Christian domination within the Congress Party. So, the Hindu believers, who are traditional voters of Indian National Congress analyse that there will be a sure chance for Christian conversions and other Christian promotional activities such as transferring the Government land for constructing churches or Prayer Halls to the Missionaries with the blessings of Smt. Margaret Alva," the memorandum, dated July 27, alleged. A copy of the memorandum is with Organiser.
The memorandum found it absolutely a paradox that a Christian activist was appointed Governor to the state, which is considered a holy land of Hindu believers all over the world. "It is almost similar to a virtual ordination of a Bishop at the supreme seat of Jagadguru Shankaracharya. It is not agreeable before the conscience of the devotees," the memorandum said.
"The Hindu believers in the Congress Party suspect that an attempt is going on for the Christianisation of holy places in Uttarakhand, transformation of Hindustan into Christianisthan. It is also suspected that all these hidden agendas were planned in advance with the knowledge of Smt. Soniaji. Christianisation is now a visible reality and Christian domination within the Congress Party as well as in other states is a fact by secluding the Hindu-Congress people from their eligible position. The question of Governorship of Uttarakhand is a relevant and fitting example of tactic and silent underplay against the Hindu followers of the Congress Party," the memorandum further said.
"The Hindu-Congress people have a legacy, historicity and patriotism from the ages. It is not fair to betray their pride and dignity. But as a matter of fact Smt. Soniaji is knowingly or unknowingly taking a special interest to avoid the dignity of the Hindu Congress majority by unduly promoting the minority religious sects for the last ten years.
"We have noticed that certain decisions and activities of Congress leadership are even against the relevance of our great Indian Freedom Movement. It is the irony of fate that the same Congress Party, which fought for freedom from British Colonialist, surrenders our prides and privileges before the American Colonialism.
"We suspect that there might be a conspiracy in appointing Smt. Margaret Alva as the Governor of Uttarakhand. The Hindu believers in Congress Party consider that even Vatican and Indian Ecclesial hierarchy could have been involved... If the Congress Party gets majority to form a Government, there will be a wide Christianisation everywhere in that state with the tactical support of Smt. Alva within a span of five years. We have reason to believe this is one of the hidden agendas of that Governorship," the memorandum said.
Labels:
2010,
Christianity,
Church,
Communist,
Comonwealth Games,
Hindu,
India,
New Delhi
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
